2026 Comparison · All Coastal States
Bahama Shutters vs Colonial Shutters
Bahama vs colonial hurricane shutters compared: cost, appearance, storm protection, and which decorative shutter is right for your coastal home.
Bahama vs colonial hurricane shutters compared: cost, appearance, storm protection, and which decorative shutter is right for your coastal home.
Bahama and colonial shutters are the two decorative hurricane shutter options — both protect in a storm and look great year-round. Bahama shutters are hinged at the top and prop open at an angle; colonial shutters are hinged on the sides and fold flat against the house. Both are popular in Florida and along the Gulf Coast for their classic coastal aesthetic.
| Category | Bahama Shutters | Colonial Shutters | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hurricane protection | ✓ Code-approved | ✓ Code-approved | Tie |
| Cost | $18–$32/sq ft ✓ | $20–$35/sq ft | Bahama Shutters |
| Shade & airflow when open | Excellent ✓ | Limited | Bahama Shutters |
| Curb appeal when open | Distinctive angle look | Flat — classic | Tie |
| Easy to close before storm | Very fast — drop and latch | Swing and latch | Tie |
| Works on doors | Not typical | Yes ✓ | Colonial Shutters |
| Historic/HOA approval | Coastal communities | Historic districts ✓ | Colonial Shutters |
| Insurance discount | 15–20% | 15–20% | Tie |
• Waterfront or tropical architecture
• Daily shade and UV protection wanted
• Lower budget
• Windows only (not doors)
• Traditional or colonial architecture
• Historic district or HOA requirements
• Door coverage needed
• Classic symmetrical exterior look